In Houston the night of April 4, the 2011 NCAA Men’s National Basketball Championship could well see a matchup of Notre Dame’s Fighting Irish (seeded #2 in the Southwest Region), lead by their scrappy senior guard Ben Hansbrough, against the Tar Heels of The University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill (Seeded #2 in the East Region).
Beyond the usual on-court analysis of playing styles and the like, this potential championship game poses an unusual question: Who would Tyler Hansbrough, the all-time Tar Heel great and current member of the NBA’s Indiana Pacers, root for – his alma mater or his younger brother?

Brotherly Love
Morganobrien.com has that answer (with audio proof). We’ll get to that in a moment. Let’s have some fun first.
As someone with family ties to both schools, I found this question intriguing and wasted spent last weekend pestering a bunch of people I follow on Twitter to get their opinions. Respondents ranged from former Tar Heel basketball players to journalists to friends of mine (responses follow story, below).
While Tyler, more than any player in recent history, embodies the Tar Heel spirit (he lead the Heels to their latest title, in 2009), most respondents said they would understand if he rooted for his brother. In fact, the overwhelming majority of respondents, starting with none other than Dickie V., replied with some form of, “Blood is thicker than water.”
While true, I clearly remember Tyler bleeding for the Heels:

Thicker than water?
My favorite responses came from Steve Rushin (who I know from Sports Illustrated, but he might be somewhere else now), who said that Tyler should to root for his “”Brough”. I also enjoyed the response from The New York Post’s Mike Vaccaro (Chaminade High School alum), who replied that “Blood (is) Thicker than Tar”. I liked Vacc’s response so much, I stole it for my headline. I would also like to take this opportunity to apologize to Keith Law, who apparently didn’t appreciate my barrage of questions.
Without further ado, here is the response from the horses mouth, courtesy of Hoopsworld.com’s Tommy Beer:
Let the record show, if the Heels and Irish play on that magical Monday night, Tommy Beer had the scoop first. In the interim, I’ll continue to pester folks for answers (I’m looking at you, Jay Bilas), and will update this page accordingly.
Notes:
There is another family, faced with this same question, albeit inversely. Star Carolina forward Tyler Zeller’s older brother, Luke, graduated from Notre Dame in 2009, where he was a standout basketball player. I’ve reached out to Luke, and will let you know if we hear from him. Perhaps he can tip the balance.
***
The UNC family could draw on a recent precedent for this question. In the 2009 tournament (In which Tyler Hansbrough lead the Heels to a national title), former Tar Heel Jason Capel supported Oklahoma over the Tar Heels. Capel’s older brother, Jeff, was the head coach of the Sooners:
Former North Carolina forward Jason Capel had no problem wearing Boomer Sooner red when Oklahoma faced his Tar Heels.
“For one day? Not at all. I was a Capel my whole life, way before I was a Tar Heel,” he said.
THE EXPERTS (AND JAY 420) WEIGH IN
Legendary Journalists
Dickie V: Blood thicker than water
UNC Alum Peter Gammons: great question (Ed. note: not really an answer, but he is Peter Gammons)
Former Tar Heels
Bobby Frasor: ND. No questions asked.
Wes Miller: heels always. That’s family too
Dewey Burke: ND. Blood comes first.
Chaminade Alumni Journalists
Mike Vaccaro (NY Post): Blood is thicker than tar.
Tommy Beer (Hoopsworld.com): I think he has to root for his bro right? He can root for UNC for rest of his life
Journalists not named Vitale/Gammons who I enjoy following on Twitter
Doug Gottleib (ESPN): Blood thicker than Blue Water.
Steve Somers (WFAN): blood is always thicker than what is it the laundry already.
Dan Levy (On the DL Podcast): Easy. Brother to do well in a close loss to his alma mater. (later) that said, if it was his son (or anyone’s son) you root for the kid, not the school.
Jeff Pearlman (CNNSI): his brother. easy.
Mark Lisanti: He seems the type to root against family.
Cindy Boren (Wash Post): I’d hope he’d go w/his bro…just this once.
Ryan Ruocco (ESPN 1050 NY): bro…blood wins always
Tao of Stieb: Shit dude, who do you think I am? Al McGuire? The most I know about college hoops is that Pervis Ellison was awesome.
Chad Moriyama: Gotta go with blood, right?
Wallace Matthews (ESPN New York): if he roots for a college over his brother, there’s something wrong in that family
Brooke Hundley: family first, but not until they’re in the big leagues, so I’d say go alma mater 
Erin Sharoni (St John’s beat): family ties are hard to break.
Baseball America: Not all BAers went to UNC! Better question for @johnmanuelba or @willlingo
Dave Sims (Mariners Broadcaster, Partner of Coach K on his satellite radio program): His bro!
Steve Rushin: Gotta go with bro. Or ‘brough, rather.
Jonah Keri (Author, The Extra 2%): Bro!
Keith Law: Continuing to ask me a question about college basketball will not change the fact that I don’t like college basketball. (Ed. note- Keith Law is so SABR, he apparently won’t even entertain a theoretical question. So meta…)
Carolina Connections
Hinton James: ah ’tis a quandry many men have faced. Though I think alma mater is thicker than blood…my bias may prevail I fear.
Molly Sullivan (Las Vegas-based reporter, UNC alum): Excellent question! I would go with our Tar Heels over Big Ben. Then again, it’s more fun to root for people than teams.
Brooke Baldwin (CNN Anchor): oooh toughie. UNC. natch.
Megg Connelly: Hansbrough dilemma is like me having to ref a mud wrestling comp btwn Andy Roddick & Philip Rivers. No matter what, I win.
People I went to Chaminade With (or wished I did)
Gene Brtalik: blood is thicker than water
Steve Reddy: brother, no doubt. I can’t believe you spent 2 hours sending that out. Bieber? Kardashian? Pauly D? SO RANDOM. Love it!
Tim Schirmer: I would and will root for whoever they play in the next round
Other Semi-Celebs
Craig Breslow (Oakland A’s): He roots for #Yale
Raynell Cooper (2011 Jeopardy Teen Challenge Champ): That’s a tough call. Probably his brother, family>alma mater
Jay 4:20 (J-Woww mentioned him on Jersey Shore): Yes, lol (Ed. note- what?)